Tebow has earned a second Heisman

Bradford wins the Heisman.  No contest.

Your first paragraph makes it sound as though Florida (aka. Tebow) has already beaten "Top Ranked Alabama".  Well last time I checked, that hasn't happened yet.  I won't say it certainly isn't possible but Alabama is in the number 1 spot for a reason - they are damn good!  Are they as good as Florida?  I don't know but they are certainly NOT among Florida's easiest games and the game has not been played yet.  I wouldn't count those chickens yet.

The jury's still out, I think we have to see the results of this weeks games. Certainly any of the Top contenders, QBs Bradford, Tebow, Harrell, McCoy  & RB Greene are worthy of the award. The Big 12 with it's intense competition might cancel each other out, and  Tebow gets his 2nd. award. It is going to be an interesting  week. Bradford & Tebow still  have a chance to impress the voters.

There should be no problem with Florida beating Alabama this weekend. If McCoy doesn't get the award, I hope Tebow does. Not Bradfor of Harrell...what everyone has to remember is that no matter how good a QB looks, he is only as good as the TEAM around him. GO LONGHORNS...

So you cry after a defeat and promise to play hard the rest of the season.  And that makes you deserve the Heisman trophy.  If it wasn't for winning last year, Tebow wouldn't even be in the race this year.

Yeah, give it to him!  Bama has a history of making Heisman trophy qb's look like they are running for their life!

During any normal college season Bradford, Harrell, or McCoy would win the Heisman.  But given the extreme play in the Big 12 South, I don't think one of them distinguished himself from the others.  So I think Tebow, who is a fantastic QB, wins b/c the Big 12 candidates will cancel each other out.

I don't get it.  I'm not saying Tebow isn't good, he is.  But last year when he won the Heisman, his team lost 3 games.  I cannot recall a Heisman winner whose team did not, well, win.  The media loves Tim Tebow.  He's a nice guy.  If I hear one more time about his missions to save the world, I am gonna vomit.  He's Jesus incarnate at ESPN so we know where those shallow minded lemmings are going to vote.  But here's the deal, the Heisman goes to the player with the greatest impact on their team.  Tell me that is not Colt McCoy.  Tell me that is not Sam Bradford.  Tebow cried when he lost to an unranked team.  Bradford shook hands with McCoy who willed Texas to beat the number 3 team in the country.  There are a lot of one loss teams.  How many of them had their loss to an unranked opponent?  Three - Penn State (no Heisman talk here), USC (again, no Heisman talk) and Florida - where Jesus lives.  And while we want to say Florida has impressively beaten teams, those teams have turned out to be mediocre: LSU (5 losses), Georgia (3 losses), South Carolina (5 losses), Tennessee (7 losses), Kentucky (6 losses), Vanderbilt (6 losses), Arkansas (7 losses), Auburn (7 losses), Mississippi State (8 losses), Mississippi (4 losses).  The only solid team is Alabama and their offense is anemic.  Florida looks great because Florida could be up by 90 points on a team and have their first string in to pad numbers to make them look better.  Style points is what they call it.  No wonder everyone hates the Gators.

I think the Heisman goes to either Bradford or McCoy and my vote is McCoy as the best all around player in the Big 12 which I think is the best conference in the country (even though I love my Buckeyes).  The only reason to bestow it on Tebow is to tie Archie's record.

Okay, Tebow who? I believe Darren McFadden was robbed of a deserving Heisman Trophy. Tebow is good but not as good as a McFadden or for that matter a Matt Jones. If Matt Jones would have had the blocking Tebow has he should have won a Heisman. Tebow is nothing without the other players. Put him at Ole Miss, Arkansas, Auburn, etc and he would be mediocre. McFadden accomplished his stats around a mediocre team. So maybe we need to give him another Heisman so we don't have to see him cry.

I'm neither a Tebow fan nor a Florida fan. I won't be thrilled if he wins again. But if he does, I'm sure that among the first to congratulate him will be Archie Griffin. That man has class!!!! Does Tebow?

I don't think Tebow is any more deserving of the Heisman than McCoy or Bradford.  All three are good QBs.

Tebow was the best last year and is still the best "ALL ROUND" football player in the nation. He could play a DB at any position..or just a running back, and blocker.                                                                                                                              Other QB's have more TD's and passing yardage, but don't have the leadership, knowledge aspects of the game.   A Tebow comes along about every 20 years.  And I'm not a Gator fan.

Go TAR HEELS..and you know who the best basketball player is... ; )

I agree that Tebow is a fine young man.  I remember watching the espn special on him before he stepped foot on the Florida campus.  But that does not constitute winning the Heisman trophy.  Why does diving for 1 yard TD's = winning a heisman trophy?

His numbers are "waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay" down from a year ago, agreeing with the above poster, McFadden should have won. 

The other QB's don't have the leadership?  All 3 QB's in the Big 12 have led their teams to 1 loss seasons, with each of those losses against Top 5 caliber teams, not a non-ranked team at home.  Bradford(OK I'm biased), McCoy, or Harrell, deserve this trophy much more than Mr. Tebow this year.

You know it really doesn't matter who wins the popularity award (aka Heisman Trophy) it ceased to mean anything years ago. Is Tebow the most valuable player in college football? No. I am not sure Bradford, McCoy or Harrell are either. How many Heisman Trophy QB's are playing at the next level? The Heisman Trophy has become equal to Prom King in high school. Lets see who wins the Maxwell Trophy that is the one for QB's.

Go Sooners!